30 of the Most Wildly Overrated Historical Figures

‘Elon Musk’
30 of the Most Wildly Overrated Historical Figures

God, there’s a lot of history. History, after all, is full of people, and all of them were doing stuff for their entire lives. It’s pretty much impossible to absorb all the information and full context for, well, the entirety of human existence. That means certain people or events obviously get overlooked. Other historical figures, however, benefit from the fact that there’s only so many pages in a history textbook

They might get to enjoy a long reign of unearned importance, just because we found their mummy first, or they had a great photographer, or they were European and white. Once you delve a little deeper into everything that’s ever happened, you realize they might not have been the centerpiece of that century, after all. 

Historians on Reddit were all too happy to volunteer their opinions on some of the most overrated people in history, and you can enjoy their historical badmouthing below.

fushiao g 6y ago Edited 6y ago Douglas Macarthur. Was obsessed with his legacy while being a far less capable leader than many of the other overlooked commanders in the Pacific theater. Не spent thousands of lives in battles on islands that had little strategic significance, declared the battle for the Philippines over while intense fighting raged on, and was disliked by many serving under him. Go listen to/read Max Hastings' Retribution: The Battle for Japan for a great deep dive into the Pacific War
Dynwynn . 6y ago Henry VIII Let's be honest, all he did was strong arm the church so he could marry another woman the fat greedy sod.
 . 6y ago Edited 6y ago Coco Chanel- I have recently found out she was apparently a Nazi agent who went under the code name 'Westminster'. She spent most of WW2 in Paris in the Ritz sleeping with Nazi officers and had direct contact to Himmler and Goebbels. She even insisted all Jewish directors of her brand be removed.
Dinosaur_from_1998 . 6y ago loannis Metaxas. Не was the leader of Greece from 1936 to1941. Most famous for not surrendering to fascist Italy during WW2. The only problem is that Metaxas was a fascist dictator himself.
i_fuckin_luv_it_mate 6y ago Tutenkhamun. Or King Tut as he is sometimes referred. Не was a boy pharoah that only reached the age of maybe 18, born from incest and suffered scoliosis a bad foot (walked with a cane) and contracted malaria, and likely died from an infection from a broken leg. Also when he came to power married his sister and had two miscarriages. This poor boy had lots of power, but was sick all his life and likely his advisors made all decisions for him and eventually succeeded him. Also had a very short reign that ended with Egypt
Expert_Witness . 6y ago Jack the Ripper. More overhyped not overrated. But he only killed 5 people. It's not like he's the original Dexter.
beepborpimajorp 6y ago Edited 6y ago Ted Bundy. People claim that in terms of serial killers he had high intelligence. Не didn't. Не dropped out of law school because he couldn't keep up with his peers. So he was of average intelligence, he's just being compared with other serial killers who overall skew lower in terms of IQ. And no, his crimes weren't clever. Не broke into the basement of a sorority house and bludgeoned 2 girls to death with a log from the fireplace while they were sleeping. The only reason he wasn't caught sooner was because the detectives
plpeter . 6 y ago . Edited 6y ago Christopher Columbus
SirLoinTheTender . 6y ago . Edited 6y ago Mother Theresa
coldcurru 6y ago Edited 6y ago Not the most overrated but first guy that comes to mind is America's only Paul Revere. Don't get me wrong, yes he was a good guy and he played a role in our nation's fate that night. But did you know he wasn't the only man on the Midnight Ride? A lot of the work and credit goes to his two peers that night. Revere only gets the credit because his name rhymed nicely in the poem written about him.
ali0yvr . 6y ago Thomas Edison
Al-Anka . 6y ago . Edited 5y ago John Lennon. Don't hurt me, I'm a big beatles fan, but somebody had to say it.
 e 6y ago Ronald Reagan. Не was always a popular President, but he has since been recast (mainly by conservative historians) as a great one as well. Yes, you can easily place him on that pedestal. You would merely need to ignore the Iran-Contra scandal, the huge budget deficits, his environment ignorance, his do-nothing reaction to the looming AIDS epidemic, his courting of Saddam Hussein, and numerous other blunders. And he didn't win the Cold War: The war in Afghanistan started in 1979. Reagan was still in California.
BfreakingD . 6y ago Stalin. literally a mass murder, still hailed to this day by a majoritiy of russians and many many other dumbass communists around the world.
 ].6y ago Steve Jobs
72Challupas . 6y ago Che Guevara. Horrible, horrible, person that somehow became a symbol of rebellion and freedom.
linguinenoodles . 6y ago Woodrow wilson
Qzeblic . 6y ago Gandhi
YouEnjoyMyself84 . 6y ago Amelia Earhart... there were plenty of trailblazing and better women pilots yet Amelia is a household name because she attempted something she died while trying.
hairyandpale . 6y ago Elon Musk.
PmMeYourDirtySecret 6y ago ® Edited 6y ago J.F. Kennedy. Не is considered to be one of the best presidents, but during his presidency he didn't accomplish a lot. Maybe, that's because his term was relatively short, but anyway he is in the history mainly because of his death. Edit: JFK wasn't bad per se. Не did some controversial stuff and did something good. But he wasn't most productive president in history and this topic isn't about being good or bad, it's about being overrated.
 . 6y ago Barack Obama. Не received a Nobel prize and is widely respected and admired, but if you really look at what he accomplished, it's pretty lackluster.
boshimonos1 . 6y ago Bill Clinton. Turns out he was just 15 years early enough to avoid the MeToo movement. Also a lot of the laws and executive order he signed led to the 2007 collapse and he is primarily to blame for the high minority incarceration rate.
chapelchain 6y ago Walt Disney One of the big reasons why copyright laws are so screwed up nowadays, which is ironic since most of his ideas were taken from the public domain (Snow White, Sleeping Beauty, Little Mermaid, just to name a few). Hell, he didn't even come up with Mickey Mouse, it was one of his animators who came up with the idea. Basically a rip-off of Max Fleischer who was better at marketing himself.
lonelyylittlealien . 6y ago Alexander Hamilton. As a girl in high school, there is no fugure I am more tired of.
layout420 6y ago Dan Don't approach me in public Marino. Не gets a ton of praise here in south FL but he's not the Charles Barkley of the NFL. Charles Barkley is often thought of as one of the best to not win a championship. Dan Marino is overrated and is a jacksss to anyone who tries to speak to him in public. You were famous, bro.... people want to get a chance to meet you. Get over yourself.
 . 6y ago Winston Churchill. Made a speech, almost lost the war but got saved by Russia and because Germany messed up a tactic.
voges101 . 6y ago karl marx
dieterschaumer 6y ago Off the top of my head Oliver Cromwell is often seen as a great Republican hero but he ruled near dictatorially and arguably committed genocide against the Irish. Woodrow Wilson is often credited as some great progressive idealist but he screened Birth of the Nation (basically pro KKK revisionism) at the white house and the League of Nations was basically just whitewashing ongoing imperialism.
Henry Ford. In business, engineering, and manufacturing, he's revered like a god. Professors like to gloss over his overwhelming anti-semitism. Ford wrote and published a wildly anti-Semitic newspaper, which were spread around the Ford Motors facilities. Those papers were republished in Germany and became incredibly popular with the Third Reich. Heinrich Himmler described Ford as one of our most valuable, important, and witty fighters. Hitler praised Ford in Mein Kampf and referred to Ford as an inspiration. The admiration went both ways, because Ford was a Nazi sympathizer to the highest degree, hosting Hitler's representatives in his home and hobnobbing

Tags:

Scroll down for the next article
Forgot Password?